Water Attacks Highlight the Necessity of Controlled Remote Access for Electric and Water Utilities
By Ethan Schmertzler | November 16, 2026
In an era where cybersecurity threats are increasingly prevalent, the need for robust remote access protocols in the electric and water utility sectors has become glaringly evident. Recent attacks on water systems serve as a stark reminder of this imperative. The alarming events that unfolded in late July, where over 30 community water systems in Minnesota fell victim to cybersecurity breaches, illustrate why controlled remote access is no longer a luxury but a necessity.
It was the early morning hours, around 2 a.m., when a critical incident occurred at a pump station or substation. Such situations necessitate immediate vendor access to diagnose and resolve the issues at hand. A well-designed control system allows the appropriate personnel to gain access swiftly while simultaneously ensuring that all unauthorized users are kept out. This crucial litmus test serves as a practical standard for utilities aiming to enhance their cybersecurity frameworks.
In North America, electric utilities have long adhered to strict regulations under the North American Electric Reliability Corporation’s Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) standards. In stark contrast, water utilities have lacked a cohesive regulatory framework, relying instead on a mix of proposed federal baselines and voluntary guidelines. Despite these differences, both sectors share similar pathways to their control systems, which often include zone boundary controllers and virtual private networks (VPNs) that may inadvertently open vulnerabilities.
As the summer of 2026 progressed, the dangers associated with insufficient cybersecurity measures became painfully clear. By August, attacks extended beyond Minnesota, affecting twelve states and prompting warnings from the FBI and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). These organizations reported that attackers managed to breach internet-facing controllers, altering critical IP addresses and passwords. The consequences were dire, as operators faced loss of monitoring capabilities, leading to potential flooding and disastrous operational disruptions.
With the cybersecurity landscape continuously evolving, companies like Dispel have noted a wide disparity in the remote access setups among their clients. On one end of the spectrum, some large organizations experience delays of up to four weeks just to onboard or off-board a vendor due to poorly managed processes. In some cases, a firewall remains open throughout this cumbersome timeframe. Conversely, there are organizations where vendors have almost unrestricted access, raising alarming questions about oversight and security.
It is important to note that possessing a VPN is insufficient for comprehensive security. Merely stating, "We have a VPN," often shuts down further discussions, but it should actually trigger deeper conversations about overall cybersecurity strategies. A VPN provides encryption and basic authentication; however, it leaves many crucial aspects unmonitored, such as details about who authorized the access, whether or not access logs are reviewed, and how to respond to suspicious activities.
To protect critical infrastructure effectively, organizations should adopt comprehensive frameworks like the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s Special Publication 1800-45, which outlines secure remote access for water utilities. These frameworks not only provide guidelines for implementing robust controls but also enable more efficient monitoring of compliance with standards like NERC CIP and IEC 62443.
However, simply introducing a framework is not enough; organizations must also establish clear procedures regarding how remote access is requested, approved, and documented. Operational teams, often burdened with multiple responsibilities, need efficient solutions that automate these processes. A modern approach to security ensures that access requests are processed quickly, facilitating audit readiness while allowing teams to focus on other essential tasks.
An updated method of just-in-time remote access is proving to be a much more effective solution compared to traditional VPNs. In this model, a vendor must request a specific session for a defined task, which must be approved by the asset owner before entry is granted. Once the task is completed, the pathway is closed, keeping the organization secure. This approach emphasizes individual accountability, as sessions are tied to specific personnel rather than shared logins.
Utilizing effective monitoring tools can provide context to security personnel at critical moments, such as during an early morning emergency. For example, when a vendor requests access to a malfunctioning pump controller, operators equipped with a risk assessment dashboard can readily assess risks and approve access based on real-time data. As a result, the vendor solves the issue efficiently, while an auditable record of activity is securely logged.
The necessity for enhanced remote access security is underscored by the experience of a municipal water utility in the southwestern United States. For seven years, this utility has maintained a single access layer that is expertly monitored and segmented from both IT and OT environments. This strategy has evolved into a reliable platform that grows more effective with use and helps streamline operations.
Overall, the challenge remains: utilities must ensure they control who can access their operational technology (OT) while providing timely access to authorized personnel. Effective solutions enable utilities to rapidly shut down unauthorized access, ensuring that they can still operate and provide essential services, even in the event of a security breach.
Dispel’s proactive response to this pressing issue is encapsulated in their Community Power & Water Program, designed to bring secure remote access solutions to smaller utilities that may lack the resources of larger entities. This program aims to bridge the cybersecurity gap and provide small water and electric utilities with the same level of protection that larger organizations rely on.
The underlying message is simple: as the cyber threat landscape evolves, so too must the strategies adopted by electric and water utilities. Continuous vigilance, secure access protocols, and well-defined frameworks are critical components in ensuring that communities are protected from the devastating impacts of cyberattacks.
