The European Commission recently made a landmark decision to fine tech giants Facebook and Apple for violations related to data privacy and competition practices. Facebook was fined 200 million euros for allegedly coercing users into consenting to their personal data being used for targeted advertising, while Apple was hit with a 500 million euro fine for failing to inform smart device users of alternative app download options.
According to the commission, Facebook failed to provide users with a genuine choice regarding the use of their personal data for advertising purposes and access to the social media platform. This fine, along with the penalty imposed on Apple, marks the first enforcement actions taken under the Digital Markets Act of 2022. This regulation aims to ensure fair competition in the tech industry and prevent major companies from abusing their market dominance.
The specific issue with Facebook arose when European data protection authorities rejected the company’s justifications for collecting personal data for advertising. In response, Facebook introduced a subscription model in November 2023 for European users, offering them the option to opt-out of personalized ads. However, critics argue that behavioral advertising infringes on users’ right to privacy unless they explicitly consent to it.
In November 2024, Facebook further modified its pay-or-consent model by introducing a no-cost option for users to view “less personalized ads.” The effectiveness of this alternative ad display method is still under evaluation by the commission. The fine imposed on Facebook only covers its actions from March 2024 to November 2024, during which it was expected to comply with the Digital Markets Act.
European executive vice president Henna Virkkunen emphasized that the fine reflects the continent’s commitment to safeguarding the rights of citizens and promoting fair competition. However, Meta, Facebook’s parent company, criticized the decision and announced its intention to appeal, claiming that the commission is unfairly targeting successful American businesses.
Similarly, Apple expressed its disagreement with the decision and pledged to challenge it, arguing that the measures imposed are detrimental to user privacy, product development, and the company’s business model. Both Meta and Apple have two months to adjust their practices and comply with the regulations outlined in the Digital Markets Act.
Prominent European privacy advocate Max Schrems lauded the commission’s actions and predicted that greater changes are imminent for Facebook. He criticized Facebook’s “less ads” option as a mere facade and accused the company of manipulating users with a false choice.
In response to the fines, Joel Kaplan, Meta’s chief global affairs officer, denounced the commission’s decision as a hindrance to American companies and insisted that it would impose significant financial burdens on Meta while diminishing the quality of its services.
As Facebook and Apple gear up to appeal the fines, the tech industry and regulatory landscape in Europe are poised for significant shifts in data privacy and competition enforcement. The outcome of these appeals could have far-reaching implications for how tech giants operate and handle user data in the European market.